Thanksgiving in October?
BY KAREN L. RANCOURT, Ph.D.
Featured image: Karen and Gary Rancourt celebrating their 60th wedding anniversary
Come hell or high water, for decades, my husband of 60 years, Gary, our daughter Heather, when she lived with us, and I would make our way to Connecticut to spend Thanksgiving with our extended family and friends. And by “extended,” we’re talking 30 to 40 people.
This gathering was important because everyone scattered for Christmas. No one wanted to tell Grammy they wouldn’t be attending. The message was clear: Be There.
“When Grammy passed away, the Be There mandate continued, with the younger generations gradually taking over.”
Whether it meant driving on the Massachusetts Turnpike in a blizzard or getting stuck in a four-hour traffic jam trying to get out of Manhattan: Be There. And sure ’nuff, we were there.
When Grammy passed away, the Be There mandate continued, with the younger generations gradually taking over.
Last year, we excitedly made all the travel arrangements to go from our winter home in Fort Lauderdale to Connecticut for Thanksgiving. I would make my traditional oyster dressing—loved by some, gag-producing for others. Of course, we would Be There.
That was until I got hit with a case of vertigo that left me dizzy as a loon for several weeks, right through the holidays. There was no way I could travel. So, we spent a quiet Thanksgiving Day at home, with me making sure not to turn my head too far left or right.
This year, our enthusiasm for making Thanksgiving travel arrangements was dulled because I was recovering from, of all damn things, a stroke—an event I’ll share with readers another time. The thought of holiday crowds at the airport, along with the possibility of delayed or canceled flights, left us feeling stressed.
Around the same time, we learned that Gary’s brother and his wife, both of whom we love dearly, would, for the first time, not be spending Thanksgiving in New England as they always had. Instead, they would spend it at their winter home in St. Petersburg, Florida.
Well, that was just a drive across the state for us.
They invited Gary and me to spend Thanksgiving with them and some of their friends, whom we knew and liked. I offered to make my oyster dressing, and they said yes; we should plan on spending Thanksgiving with them.
At first, we felt great relief that we would be with family and friends without the hassle of flying. But then the sadness set in. We wouldn’t be with siblings, in-laws, nieces, nephews, great-nieces and great-nephews, and the close friends we see only at Thanksgiving in Connecticut.
Hmm.
Out of my sadness came an idea I shared with Gary: Who says Thanksgiving has to be celebrated on the fourth Thursday in November?
After all, 17 other countries around the world celebrate their own versions of Thanksgiving, in various months of the year.
Why don’t we host “Thanksgiving in October?”
We live at the Jersey Shore during the summer and fall months, so getting to Connecticut, which is central to many of our extended family and friends, is easy for us.
Gary loved the idea.
“Are we starting a new tradition? We’re not sure. Perhaps.
We’ll see how this plays out.”
And so, on Sunday, October 18, at a favorite restaurant on the Connecticut coast, we are hosting Thanksgiving in October for about 35 family members and friends.
We weren’t sure how the idea would be received. But the response was quick and enthusiastic. Those who already had plans that couldn’t be changed expressed their sincere regrets.
We’re not replacing our extended family’s traditional Thanksgiving in November. They will still be celebrating. What we’ve planned is in addition to that.
Are we starting a new tradition? We’re not sure. Perhaps. We’ll see how this plays out.
As I wrote in an earlier column, we get to make choices about our family traditions. We can:
1. Embrace tradition.
It is fine just the way it is—end of story.
For example, everyone in my family looked forward to the cake with apricot and banana frosting that our mother made only for birthdays.
2. Endure the tradition.
Every year, our great-grandmother made holiday cookies that were as hard as cement. She was so excited and pleased to distribute them.
Our mother instructed us to accept the cookies graciously: “But don’t you dare try to bite into one. You’ll break a tooth.”
3. Modify the tradition.
When our father suffered a stroke and had a feeding tube, our mother, who had always hosted Thanksgiving at their home, asked a nearby grandson and his wife to host that particular year.
She didn’t want our father to have to endure all the wonderful Thanksgiving aromas—the baking pumpkin and apple pies, the roasting turkey, and all the fixings—none of which he could eat.
Everyone in the family was happy to make this modification for him.
4. End the tradition.
Our daughter and her husband enjoyed playing “Elf on the Shelf” for a few years with my younger grandson.
The gist is that this little elf—a doll you purchase, with books and videos also available—hides somewhere in the house and reports back to Santa each night, telling him whether the child was good or bad that day. Parents hide the elf each night, and the child tries to find its new hiding place each morning.
I should point out that there are criticisms of the Elf on the Shelf, suggesting that the whole thing is crass commercialism and that the basic concept could be scary for children. In our family, putting those objections aside, we had fun hiding the elf and watching our youngster search for it.
Traditions end for all sorts of reasons: changes in geography, changes in family relationships, or, in this case, because the participants simply outgrow them.
5. Pass the torch.
Someone else takes over responsibility for the tradition.
This one can get a bit emotional, depending on how the “keeper of the tradition” feels about giving up responsibility for it.
And now I’m adding a sixth possibility:
6. Add a tradition.
That’s what we’re doing this year.
We’re not abandoning Thanksgiving. We’re not replacing the old tradition. We’re simply making room for another opportunity to gather the people we love.
And perhaps that’s one of the wonderful things about family traditions: They aren’t carved in stone. They can grow, change, move, and even multiply as families do.
So, here’s to our first—and perhaps not our last—Happy Thanksgiving in October!